Back

Putnam Burdick Biographical Essay

Reference material supporting the captioned biological essay, keyed to the footnotes in the text, is available as follows.

References
  • [01]  1850 U.S. Census - Erin, Macomb County, MI, pg 185
  • [02] Burdick Family Association, Burdick Newsletter, May/June 2001, and Winter 2011, Howard E. Burdick, Frisco, TX
  • Note: Coincidentally, Agawam (Springfield) was also the location at that time (1633-1635) of the Burt and Hub-bard families, in-laws of the Burtons, so it seems likely that these families would have been acquainted.
  • [04] Genealogical and Family History of the State of Vermont, Hyram Carlton, Vol II, pg. 137
  • [05] Documents and Records Relating to the State of New Hampshire, 1776-1783, Vol VIII, pg. 293
  • [06] Hudson-Mohawk Genealogical and Family Memoirs, Vol II, 1921, Cuyler Reynolds, pgs 660-661
  • [07] History of Princeton, Civil and Ecclesiastical, Jeremiah Lyford Hanaford, Worcester, 1852, pg. 89.Rev.Goodrich was ultimately offered compensation of about £200, which would amount to upwards of $104,000 in today's dollars.
  • [08] History of Wyoming County, N.Y., "The Town of Gainesville," F.W. Beers & Co., 1880 - pg. 190-196
  • [09] Ibid. 8; pg 191, the Second Congregational Church
  • [10] Family Records of Winslows and their Descendants in America, Vol. II, Holton & Holton, 1888, pg. 560
  • [11] Individual Record – Sheffield David Silliman (Pellerin Family Tree)
  • [12] History Of Macomb County, Michigan; M. A. Lesson & Co., Chicago, 1882 Armada Biographies, pg 691
  • [13] New York, 1820-1850 Passenger and Immigration Lists - Andreas Hipp Family
  • [14] Waber/Fritz Family Tree - Andreas Hipp Family
  • [15] 1850 U.S. Census, Huron County, Ohio, pg 272
  • [16] 1850 U.S. Census, Armada, Macomb County, Michigan, pg 32
  • [17] A Brief Sketch Of The Life Of Charles B. Slyfield, May 9th, 1912, C. B. Slyfield, Frankfort, Michigan; containing a reference to boarding with "a man by the name of Putnam Burdick" who lived along the shore some two miles from the lighthouse.
  • Note: The Burdicks as far back as the eighteenth century in Rhode Island were Sabbatarian Baptists, later be-coming more commonly affiliated with the Congregational and Presbyterian churches.
  • [19] 1818 Birth and Christening Record - Theresia Hipp. This is thought to have been Melissa Burdick, who is variously referred to as "Mellissa," "Malissa," and "M. Theresa Hipp," by virtue of matching birth and immigration dates, and her claimed birthplace.
  • [20] Detroit Post and Tribune, 4 Jul 1882, "Good and Faithful Servant"
  • [21] Ibid. 17
  • [22] Bible owned by Mrs. J. France, Michigan Center, MI, per Howard Burdick, Burdick Family Assn.
  • Note: Both the Burtons and the Burdicks were connected through marriage to the Samuel Hubbard family, early settlers at Agawam, which eventually became Springfield, Massachusetts.
  • [24] Seventeenth Annual Report of the Secretary of the State Horticultural Society of Michigan, 1887, "Mani-tou County," pg 395.
  • [25] 1870 U.S. Agricultural Census, Manitou County, Michigan
  • [26] Slyfield Land Patents and Plat Map, Bureau of Land Management
  • [27] Ibid. 17
  • [28] Seeing the Light, Keepers of the Point Betsie Light Station, Terry Pepper, www.terrypepper.com
  • [29] 1859 Death Record, Silver Lake Twp, Leelanau County, MI - Mary Slyfield
  • [30] Ibid. 17
  • [31] Map showing probably Putnam Burdick farm location, based on South Manitou Island, From Pioneer Community to National Park, Myron H. Vent, pg 34, where the author asserts that the original Burdick farm "was adjacent to that of the (George Johann) Hutzlers." Putnam Burdick never actually owned any land until some ten years after having arrived on South Manitou Island, but most islanders began as "squatters" on preempted land, which they later acquired through homestead claims or outright purchase. The only land Putnam Burton eventually owned that was adjacent to the Hutzler farm as the 80-acres in S½NE-34/T31N,R15W (see map in [32].) That parcel was one of his last acquisitions, and was paid for in cash, rather than military bounty land warrants, as were all his other holdings. (Under preemption rules, there was no need to purchase such land until someone else made an offer to buy it.)
  • [32] Putnam Burdick Land Patents and Plat Map - Bureau of Land Management
  • [33] Plat Map of South Manitou Island, c.1900
  • [34] Industrial Chicago, 1891, Goodspeed Publishing Co. , Chicago - pgs 784-786
  • [35] Burial Record for James Putnam Burdick at Wayne County's Mount Hazel Cemetery
  • [36] 1880 U.S. Census for Glen Arbor Township, pg 3 - Place of residence determined on the basis of border is John Blanchfield, a Surfman at the Glen Haven USLSS Station, and neighbors John E. Fisher, former saw mill and inn operator at Glen Haven; Bishop Tucker, John Tobin and Welby Ray, farmers and USLSS Surfmen at the Glen Haven Station.
  • [37] A notation in bible owned by Mrs. J. France, Michigan Center, Mich. merely states "Anna drowned in Lake Michigan." The Burdick's eldest child appears in the September 9, 1850 Census for Erin, Michigan as 8-year old "Alvira," born in Michigan, and in the 1860 Census for South Manitou Island as "Ann E." This census data corresponds with a birth date between August 1, 1841 and September 9, 1842, the me-dian being Feb 19, 1842. The name is assumed to have been "Anna Elvira Burdick."
  • [38] 1850 U.S. Census- Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. William Moore Smith was apparently the youngest son of Mary Grant Smith, divorced or widowed daughter of Samuel Grant, a wealthy merchant in Philadelphia.
  • [38] United States Soldiers of the Civil War Residing in Michigan, June 1, 1894
  • [38] Ency-clopedia of Pennsylvania biography, Volume 13, John Woolf Jordan, 1921, pg 98.
  • [38] The New England Historical and Genealogical Register - 1873, pgs 224-225
  • [39] Grand Traverse Herald, August 10, 1866
  • [40] 1880 U.S. Census - Glen Arbor Twp, Leelanau Co, MI - William & Jane Smith at Port Onieda
  • [41] Orra Haskell birth record - born in 1870 at St. Charles, Michigan to Wellington and Estella Haskell. Includes death record of Wellington Haskill (father), birth record of Wellington Haskill Jr (brother), and marriage record of Ora Haskell to George F. Smith (name variously spelled "Haskill" and "Haskall")
  • [42] 1900 U.S. Census - Traverse City, MI, Sheet 19
  • [43] 1905 Death Records - William Moore Smith and Mary Jane (Burdick) Smith
  • [44] 1870 U.S. Census, Cadiz, Green County, Wisconsin - pg 2
  • [45] 1870 U.S. Census, St. Ansgar, Iowa, pg 16
  • [46] History of Winneshiek and Allamakee counties, Iowa, By W. E. Alexander, 1889, pgs 197, 199 & 202
  • [47] Civil War service records for the six sons of Nelson and Almira Burdick.
  • [48] Ibid. 45, pgs 208 and 551-553
  • [49] Past and Present of Winneshiek County, Iowa, Vol 2, 1913, Ch. VIII, "The Boys in Blue," pg 110
  • [50] 1880 U.S. Census, Sumner Township, Buchanan County, IA, pg 8
  • [50] "Individual Records for Ava Ann Burdick"
  • [50] Marriage Record for George S. Burdick and Mary Jane Spece
  • [51] Birth/Death record for Mary Burdick, daughter of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [52] Birth/Marriage/Death record for Nellie Burdick, daughter of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [53] 1920 U.S. Census: Homer, Iowa
  • [53] Birth/Death record for Arthur Burdick, son of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece. Arthur Burdick, son of George S. Burdick and Mary Jane Spece, apparently never married, and wound up in the house-hold of, and working as a hired man for, dray line owner George Beatty in his shop at Homer, Iowa. George Beatty married George's sister, Ava Ann Burdick.
  • [54] Birth/Marriage/Death record for Thomas Burdick, son of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [55] Birth/Death record for Amos Burdick, son of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [56] Birth/Marriage/Death record for Elizabeth Burdick, daughter of George S. Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [57] Birth/Marriage/Death record for George Sheffield Burdick
  • [58] Birth/Marriage/Death record for Sarah Jane Spece
  • [59] Burial Records - George S Burdick and Sarah Jane Spece
  • [60] Plat map showing locations of Andrew & Sarah Burdick farm, Thomas & Mary Price Farm, and the island cemetery on South Manitou Island
  • [61] Coming Through With Rye, A Historic Agricultural Landscape Study of South Manitou Island at Sleeping Bear National Lakeshore, Michigan, Brenda Wheeler Williams, et al, National Park Service, 1996, pg 136 (or Digital Edition - pg 142)
  • [62] The History of the American Expedition Fighting the Bolsheviki - Campaigning in North Russia 1918-1919, Joel R. Moore, Harry H. Mead, and Lewis E. Jahns, Polar Bear Publishing, Detroit, 1920
  • [63] According to Charles M. Anderson, author of Isle of View, A History of South Manitou Island, (pg 39,) there was always some question about who is actually buried in Andrew T. Burdick's grave. The U.S. Army supposedly returned two caskets aboard the train to Traverse City, one being somewhat shorter than the other. The other soldier was the son of Dr. & Mrs. Murphy, of Maple City, who was the taller of the two young men, however the casket they received was the shorter one, leading them to believe there had been a mix-up. On informing Captain Anderson of their fear that their son having been mistakenly buried on South Manitou, he suggested that they quietly honor the grave of the soldier they had buried, and the islanders would do the same. Perhaps this is just another of the island's many "ghost stories."
  • [64] According to his headstone in the cemetery on South Manitou Island, and contrary to the date published in the Nellie Johnson family genealogy study.
  • [65]Ibid. 63
  • [66] Mary Elizabeth Burdick and Flora Burdick Burials at Maple Grove Cemetery in Empire Township, MI